NOI / VOL·I · ES Image archive ↗
Act I · 03 · Convergence, 2011 – 2014

Cicada, the Pentagon story, and GreenZone

In one line2011–2014 is where they meet, and where an anonymous puzzle first acquires someone claiming to own it.

This is where the two halves fuse. Schoenberger starts telling a covert-operations story about himself using Flynn's business partner as the alibi. Flynn leaves DIA and walks straight into Kian's chip company. And a puzzle from 2012 acquires an owner who did not write it.

2009 – 2018 · the soilDocumented

The Tea Party: the audience Q inherited

Q did not have to build a movement from scratch. It walked into one. The Tea Party, born in 2009 against Obama, bailouts and "big government," trained millions of people in a specific way of seeing politics: Washington is captured, the media lies, the president is illegitimate, and ordinary "patriots" have to take the country back. Birtherism, the claim that Obama was not born in the United States, was the movement's first mass conspiracy theory.

The clearest bridge is Jerome Corsi. He was the Tea Party's favorite conspiracy writer and the leading birther author, with a 2011 book arguing Obama's birth certificate was fake. In December 2017, by then working for Infowars, he took up QAnon, decoded "drops" on air and told viewers to help "research" the clues. Alex Jones said Corsi had been asked to cover the "8chan beat."

The ideas carried over almost intact. "Patriots," the illegitimate Obama, the captured state that later gets the name "deep state," the elites who will finally be arrested, the idea that you do your own research because the media won't. QAnon added the game and the prophecy. The audience, the vocabulary and many of the broadcasters were already there.

The thread runs straight through this file. In early 2018, while Corsi was decoding Q for a mass audience, Schoenberger was writing to him in private as Q, from the address a858de45f56d9bc9@aol.com, a string taken from the Reddit A858 puzzle (from my archive). On the other side of the line, back in 2010, Neal Rauhauser and his associates ran "TwitterGate," parody accounts aimed at Tea Party members: the same fake-persona craft, eight years earlier, pointed at the same audience.

Steve Pieczenik says it himself. On the Alex Jones Show on October 10, 2016, the day after the second Trump–Clinton debate,, he thanks Bannon and Kushner for "the most brilliant psychological operation" and then: "We, who fought from the day one since 9-11 and created the Tea Party to help you with the Alex Jones Show, have now a spokesperson for that revolution." A former State Department official, on the biggest conspiracy broadcast in the country, claiming the Tea Party as his own and handing it to Trump, a year before Q.

And the bridge reached the top. Ginni Thomas, a Tea Party organizer since 2009 (Liberty Central) and wife of Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas, texted White House chief of staff Mark Meadows in November 2020 urging him to look into the claims of Steve Pieczenik, the same man who in 2016 announced a "counter-coup" on video.

I covered this in a 2019 livestream: QAnon and the Tea Party ↗ · Sources: SPLC, 2012, Media Matters, Raw Story on the Thomas texts.

May 2, 2011 · Napa County Superior CourtDocumented

The same year as the "Pentagon mission": a felony stalking plea

In 2011, the year Schoenberger later says the Pentagon invited him onto a covert mission across 17 countries, he was in a Napa courtroom. In People v. Schoenberger, Thomas Andrew, case CR155849, he entered a plea of no contest to felony stalking under California Penal Code § 646.9(a) on May 2, 2011, and was put on probation.

He did not finish it clean. On January 8, 2015, he admitted a petition for violation of probation. Judge Mark Boessenecker revoked and reinstated probation, added 10 more days in county jail on top of the time already ordered, and ordered him to pay $5,500 in restitution to the victim, with 10% annual interest.

"Charges: Felony - Stalking [PC646.9(A)]; Nolo Plea on 05-02-11 … Defendant admits Petition for Violation of Probation filed December 12, 2014 … Additional 10 days in the County Jail consecutive to his previously ordered time."

Superior Court of California, County of Napa · minute order, Jan 8, 2015 · police report no. NPD10-7746 · the victim's name is withheld here.

This matters for everything that follows. The man who later sues researchers for calling him a harasser, and who presents himself as a target of online stalking, has a stalking conviction on his own record, from the period when he was building the Cicada and "covert operations" story.

2011Claimed

The "top secret" mission across 17 countries

Schoenberger says the Pentagon invited him onto a covert mission spanning 17 countries, which he says he shut down himself upon discovering ISIS knew their movements. He names Bijan Kian as his Pentagon contact and Seval Oz — Dr. Oz's sister — as his partner.

Treat the mission as fiction and the names as the finding. He does not invent contacts at random; he borrows real people who are adjacent to real money, and Kian is precisely that.

Notes flag a detail worth keeping: a QAnon account using "OZ" imagery and Schoenberger's own account are two of the nine accounts William Binney follows.

Oct 12, 2011 · same-day resonanceDocumented

Scheuer and Robert David Steele publish the same Iran theory on the same day

Robert David Steele · phibetaiota.net

Writes that the "Iranian assassination plot" may be an Israeli false flag.

Michael Scheuer · YouTube

Same day, same position, same framing.

Two former officers, two platforms, one date. Coordination is not proven by synchrony alone — but synchrony is what you log first and explain later.

2012 – 2014Documented

Seymour Hersh and Flynn's DIA — a running channel

Through this period Hersh appears to be receiving material from Flynn while Flynn heads DIA. The reports embarrass the lobby pushing for escalation in Syria and the removal of Assad. Hersh reports that Flynn's DIA kept sending classified warnings about the consequences of toppling Assad, and Flynn tells him the reports met enormous resistance inside the Obama administration. The grievance that later becomes a movement starts as an internal memo nobody read.

2012 · referenceDocumented

Cicada 3301 — the actual thing, before anyone claimed it

A puzzle organization recruiting codebreakers. Nobody knows who posted it. Puzzles ran in 2012, 2013 and 2014; the third has never been solved.

Everything in the Cicada Layer chapter below depends on holding this line: the puzzle is real, anonymous, and unowned. Every subsequent ownership claim is a claim about a vacuum.

2012Documented

"The US fabricated the Iran assassination charge"

Ray McGovern and Steve Pieczenik each say on Infowars that the government lied about the alleged Iranian assassination plot. Same claim as the October 2011 pairing, now moved from blogs onto the largest conspiracy broadcast in the country. That is the escalator this network runs on.

2012Documented
Nowruz Commission logo

Kian and Alptekin — EA Havacilik and the Nowruz Commission

Talking Points Memo article headlined This DC Nonprofit Brings Together Key Players In Flynn Turkey Lobbying Mess, with the Nowruz Commission logo
TPM on the Nowruz Commission as the under-the-radar link between Flynn, Kian and Alptekin. Two details worth carrying: former CNN anchor Rudi Bakhtiar was paid $1,200 to interview Turkish generals at the 2014 gala and told the WSJ that Kian, a family friend, brought her in under false pretenses without disclosing the work was for Flynn's firm — "I never would have done it" — and Sergey Kislyak sat on the commission's list of ambassadors.

Business relationship

Kian and Alptekin are doing business together before Flynn Intel Group takes foreign work. Alptekin confirms Kian served as vice chairman of his Istanbul aviation firm EA Havacilik from November 2011, and that the two regularly planned how to build an aviation client base.

Nowruz Commission

Both sit on the Nowruz Commission — the social venue where the Flynn introduction happens a year later.

2012 · Benghazi triangleUnverified

Butowski / Lara Logan / Matt Couch

Butowski claims the Benghazi story originated with him. Logan's Benghazi reporting was retracted. Couch claims serious sourcing. The same three names resurface in the Seth Rich campaign four years later, which is the reason the fragment stays in the file.

Lara Logan and Joseph Burkett at the Gracie Awards; text: in 2008 Logan married Joseph W. Burkett, a defense contractor she met while stationed in Baghdad for CBS News; Burkett was an employee of the Lincoln Group, a now-shuttered strategic communications firm hired by the Department of Defense in 2005 to plant positive stories in Baghdad newspapers
Context on Logan. Her husband, Joseph W. Burkett, worked for the Lincoln Group, the Pentagon contractor paid in 2005 to place stories in Iraqi newspapers. Public reporting: Gawker, "Lara Logan's husband was a propagandist for the U.S. military."
Apr 30, 2014Documented

Flynn announces retirement — "Flynn facts" — and goes into business with Kian

flynn.retirement2014-04-30
// Colin Powell, in leaked email:
"abusive with staff, didn't listen, worked against policy, bad management."
// NYT: a loose relationship with facts; subordinates coined the term
"Flynn facts"
// his account: forced out for challenging the "al-Qaeda is nearly defeated" line
// Hersh: Flynn confirms the agency kept sending classified warnings on Assad

Pushed out by the Obama administration, the Kian friendship converts into a business partnership. Kian brings him onto the board of the chip company GreenZone Systems Inc. Flynn's own financial disclosures show GreenZone and its parent paid him over $150,000 in cash.

2013 – 2014 · GreenZone boardDocumented

Woolsey, Justin Freeh, Kian, Flynn — and a meeting that ends early

The 2013 Nowruz Commission annual dinner in DC: Flynn presents an award to Kian's wife, and Woolsey introduces Flynn to Kian. Flynn's DIA clearance process is what qualifies the "green zone chips" pitch.

The board is Woolsey, Justin Freeh (son of Louis Freeh — the same Freeh from the Kazeminy penthouse), Kian and Flynn. They meet Miles Taylor at DHS ostensibly about chips, then abruptly pivot the conversation to removing Gulen. Taylor ends the meeting on the spot.

They fall back on Hill relationships and begin meeting Dana to build support for Midwest nuclear plants — behind which sits Russian money.

src → bloomberg.com, "What Michael Flynn Could Tell the Russia Investigators"

early 2014Claimed

Schoenberger arrives in the Cicada 3301 forums — the film-rights play

He begins posting in the Cicada forums and making assertions about the game. Shortly after he starts publishing his own puzzles and presenting them as the work of Cicada's original anonymous authors. The objective is legible and stated plainly in the notes: produce enough material to look like the inventor, and thereby hold IP for a film. His partners are Hollywood composer Michael Levine and Richard Lech.

An anonymous organization cannot rebut a claimant. That is not a side effect of the strategy — it is the strategy.

late 2014 · depositionDocumented

$90,000 from Amadeus LLC, and where it went

Recounted in the December 2015 deposition as "a little over a year" earlier: Schoenberger receives $90,000 paid through the Kazeminy-formed Amadeus LLC, then writes a series of checks.

$25,000× 1
$30,000× 1
$12,500× 3 = $37,500
  • One $12,500 check went to Brian Weiner.
  • Roughly $25,000 went to a car.
Aug & Oct 2014 · blogDocumented

Pieczenik defends Flynn twice, in public, before anyone else does

2014-08-03
Quotes the just-departed DIA director Flynn:
"If Hamas is destroyed, the region ends up with something far worse."
Then Nietzsche: "When the gods are cruel, they grant your wish."
Context given: in 2009 Hamas destroyed the Rafah mosque where Jund Ansar Allah
was born, killing 22 members including its leader.
2014-10-02
"Our president throws the intelligence community under the bus
every time he might have been wrong about going to war."
On blame landing on Flynn (DIA) and Clapper (DNI):
like a marathon runner blaming the shoes instead of himself.
// scribd · Tracking MerOz doc #306181723
2014Claimed

Schoenberger's trip to Turkey

He says he traveled to Turkey to meet Kurdish rebels out of personal concern that ISIS would break through, that he was on the Syrian border, that he spent his time handing cash to street kids, and that he carried the maximum currency legally permitted. The last detail is the only one that is checkable, and it is the only one that would matter.

Page 39 of a deposition transcript in which the witness says he went into Turkey to gather former special-ops personnel to train Kurdish forces against ISIS
Under oath, Dec 1, 2015. Page 39 of the deposition in Gauthier v. Schoenberger (Los Angeles Superior Court, BC564759). The answer is his. That he said it under oath is documented; that the trip happened as he describes is still only his claim. The plaintiff's name is blurred.
Jun & Aug 2014Documented

Open-source intelligence, and the VIPS letter to Merkel

June 2014

Robert David Steele gives an interview about his open-source intelligence project.

August 2014 · VIPS → Merkel

Binney co-signs the VIPS open letter urging the German chancellor to doubt US intelligence on a Russian invasion of Ukraine:

The accusation of a large-scale Russian incursion does not appear to rest on reliable intelligence. It resembles instead the same questionable, politically processed material used to justify the Iraq war twelve years earlier.

↑